Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has recently drawn attention to a critical issue within the Ethereum network—staking centralization. In a blog post published on October 18, 2024, Buterin emphasized that centralization poses a significant threat to the decentralized nature of Ethereum, particularly in how blocks are constructed and staking capital is provided. As Ethereum approaches its next upgrade, dubbed “Scourge,” Vitalik Buterin has outlined solutions aimed at addressing these risks to secure the blockchain’s future.
Staking Centralization: A Growing Risk for Ethereum
Vitalik Buterin identifies staking centralization as one of the most pressing challenges facing Ethereum Layer 1 (L1). This centralization occurs primarily at two critical points:
- Block Construction: Presently, around 88% of Ethereum blocks are constructed by just two major actors, consolidating power and increasing the risk of transaction censorship. Such centralization is dangerous in a blockchain designed to foster decentralization, transparency, and openness. If a small group of entities controls the block-building process, they could potentially censor transactions and undermine Ethereum’s fundamental values.
- Provision of Staking Capital: Centralization is also evident in the way staking capital is supplied. While approximately 30% of Ethereum’s total supply is currently staked—enough to protect the network from 51% attacks—the concentration of staked Ether in a few hands is a growing concern. Vitalik Buterin warns that if this figure continues to rise unchecked, it could weaken the security of the network by reducing the effectiveness of staking and leading to excessive issuance of Ether (ETH).
Proposed Solutions: Protecting Ethereum’s Decentralization
To counter these centralization trends, Vitalik Buterin proposes several innovative solutions, which he hopes will be implemented in the Scourge upgrade. These include:
- Encrypted Memory Pools (Mempools): One of the proposed solutions is to introduce encrypted mempools, which would make it harder for block proposers to censor specific transactions. By encrypting transaction details until they are included in a block, this approach aims to level the playing field and reduce the ability of centralized actors to dictate which transactions are processed.
- Inclusion Lists: Vitalik Buterin also suggests the use of inclusion lists, where stakers propose a list of transactions that builders are required to include in the next block. This would ensure that block proposers do not have the final say over transaction selection, thereby mitigating the risk of censorship by decentralized stakers.
Also read: Indicted NYC Mayor Eric Adams’ Crypto Promises Under Scrutiny Amid Legal Troubles
Reforming the Staking System
In addition to block construction, Buterin has raised concerns about the staking capital itself. The growing percentage of Ether being staked, though beneficial in protecting against attacks, brings its own set of risks. Buterin proposes a few ways to prevent the negative side effects of an overly centralized staking system:
- Staking Limits: One option is to limit the amount of Ether a single user can stake. By enforcing a cap on staked assets per user, Ethereum can distribute staking power more evenly across the network, ensuring that no single entity holds too much influence.
- Two-Tier Staking System: Another solution under consideration is a two-tier staking system, where staked Ether would be divided into two categories: reducible and non-reducible portions. The reducible part would be more vulnerable to slashing (penalties for malicious activity), while the non-reducible part would be less exposed to such risks. This dual system would balance the need for network security with the prevention of staking dominance.
Upcoming Ethereum Fork: Pectra
These proposals come as part of Ethereum’s broader plan to maintain a balance between Layer 1 (L1) and Layer 2 (L2) fees while preparing for increased traffic on the network. The upcoming Pectra fork, scheduled for late 2024 or early 2025, will integrate many of these innovations, laying the groundwork for Ethereum’s next phase of growth.
Vitalik Buterin’s suggestions align with Ethereum’s long-term vision of creating a more accessible and decentralized ecosystem. By addressing staking centralization, Ethereum aims to uphold its principles of decentralization, protect against censorship, and ensure that it can handle mass adoption without compromising its core values.
